Every turntable gift guide should open with one question, and most skip it: does the recipient own anything to plug it into? A component turntable — the kind that sounds good — makes no sound on its own. It needs powered speakers, or an amplifier and speakers, or at minimum a Bluetooth speaker and a deck that can transmit to it. An all-in-one has speakers in the case and works the moment it is plugged in, and the cheapest all-in-ones are the ones that damage records.
So this page is arranged by that answer. The first picks work alone or with a speaker almost everyone already owns. The middle picks are for someone who has, or will be given, powered speakers. The last are for the recipient who asked for a real turntable and will be happy to buy speakers themselves — the ones that stay good for years and can be upgraded rather than replaced.
Two rules hold across all of them. First, every deck here has a proper magnetic cartridge, because the ceramic pickups in the cheapest suitcase players track heavily enough to wear records — the published tracking figures are here, and a person who loves records will know exactly what a suitcase means. Second, no price is quoted in the text. The buttons carry the live figure and the date it was read.
Which one, by recipient
- A first turntable for someone who has a Bluetooth speaker or powered speakers. The Audio-Technica AT-LP60X. It is fully automatic — one button cues, plays and returns the arm — so there is nothing to set up wrong on Christmas morning, and its built-in preamp means it plugs straight into powered speakers. It has no Bluetooth of its own, so if their only speaker is wireless, choose the Sony instead. The full review.
- A teenager, a dorm, a kitchen, or anyone with no speakers at all. The Victrola Eastwood II is the one all-in-one on this site we would give. It has speakers in the case, a replaceable Audio-Technica cartridge instead of a ceramic one, and Bluetooth out — so it works alone on day one and can send sound to a better speaker later instead of being thrown away. The all-in-ones compared.
- Someone whose speaker is a wireless one. The Sony PS-LX310BT transmits to a Bluetooth speaker or headphones, is fully automatic, and also has a wired output for later. It is the deck that connects to whatever they already own, which is the safest property a gift can have. The full review.
- Someone who will play it every day. The Audio-Technica AT-LP70X keeps the one-button automation and adds a real step-up cartridge and a die-cast platter. It is the gift when the LP60X feels like too little and a manual deck feels like too much to ask of them. The automatics compared.
- Someone who asked for a “proper” turntable. The Fluance RT81. Manual, with an adjustable counterweight and anti-skate, a genuine elliptical cartridge and a switchable built-in preamp. It is the site’s best turntable overall and the one on this page that will not be outgrown; it needs powered speakers, and it asks its owner to cue the arm by hand, which the kind of person who asks for a proper turntable will enjoy. The full review.
- A parent or grandparent with CDs, cassettes and a radio habit. The Crosley Musician plays all of them in one walnut cabinet with a cueing lever. It is not hi-fi and it does not pretend to be; it is the format-everything gift for someone who wants one box. The combos compared.
What to put in the box with it
A turntable arrives with a stylus, a mat and no music. Three things make the gift complete on the day rather than complete after a second trip to the shop:
- A record. Fleetwood Mac’s Rumours is the safest single record on this site to put in a box — canonical, cheap, in print, and forgiving of a beginner learning to cue. The first ten records has the rest.
- A carbon fiber brush. The one habit that keeps a new collection quiet, and it costs very little. The under-$50 page has it.
- Speakers, if the deck needs them. For the AT-LP60X, LP70X or RT81, a pair of powered speakers turns the box into a system. The Edifier R1280T is the site’s default pick and it usually costs less than the deck. Speakers for a turntable compared.
The two mistakes
Buying a component deck for someone with nothing to plug it into. It will sit in the box until January. If you do not know what they own and cannot ask, the Eastwood II or the Sony are the decks that work regardless.
Buying a suitcase because it is cheap and looks the part. The cheapest all-in-ones use a ceramic cartridge tracking at several times the force of a magnetic one. If the recipient already loves records, it is the one gift that can make things worse. Do cheap turntables ruin records? has the numbers.
If the budget is bigger
Above the RT81 the right gift depends on the recipient’s room and their existing system, which is exactly the information a gifter usually lacks. If you know they have an amplifier with a phono input and a pair of speakers, the under-$500 and under-$1,000 roundups are written for that buyer. If you do not, the RT81 plus a good pair of powered speakers is a better gift than a more expensive deck alone.